Complaints against youth treatment facilities leads to Ohio legislation
COLUMBUS, Ohio (WCMH) — Ohio lawmakers are responding to reports of frequent violence, abuse and neglect at some of the youth residential treatment facilities operating under state licensure.
According to sponsor Rep. Crystal Lett (D-Columbus), House Bill 811 is partially inspired by a troubling series of incidents, documented by the Marshall Project, at the Fox Run Center for Youth and Adolescents in St. Clairsville and the Mohican Young Star Academy in Perrysville.
“These are egregious offenses coming out of both of these facilities,” Lett said. “These are some of our most vulnerable kids in the entire state of Ohio and for us to have a communication breakdown about serious assaults that are happening amongst other things is to me a dereliction of our duty”
According to Lett, local law enforcement is generally diligent about documenting the violence, escape attempts and allegations of ill treatment and improper restraint at such facilities. State agencies responsible for holding them accountable, however, can be slow to respond.
Eric Wandersleben, a spokesperson for the Department of Behavioral Health, said in an email that the department has suspended new admissions to the Mohican Young Star Academy and has initiated proceedings to revoke the facility’s license pending a report by an independent examiner.
Last month, federal agents arrested Fox Run’s former CEO, Randall MacKendrick, on child pornography and coercion charges. MacKendrick is also alleged to have been in contact with a 17-year-old former Fox Run resident.
“The department is aware of developments concerning the former CEO and has been in contact with the new leadership at Fox Run,” Wandersleben said. “As a result of these allegations, Fox Run terminated Mr. Mackendrick. DBH will investigate any complaints related to Fox Run and take all appropriate actions within its authority.”
Agencies like DBH have the option to crack down on facilities with a pattern of violating standards, but H.B. 811 would make those consequences mandatory. If passed, DBH would be required to either suspend admissions to a troubled residential facility or strip that facility of its license.
Rep. Andrea White (R-Kettering), chair of the House Children and Human Services Committee, praised H.B. 811 and said she hopes to see the same accountability requirements become standard for other state agencies that license residential facilities.
“There needs to be much more focus and accountability, quicker and more urgently,” White said. “Our children that are already so traumatized should not be in places that revictimize them.”
According to Addison Torrence, a former resident at the Sequel Pomegranate youth facility in Columbus, “the process of revoking the license, suspending admissions dragged on for years even after the abuse was made very public; it’s really disheartening.”
Sequel Pomegranate shut down in 2021 after reports of abuse and violence at the facility came to the state’s attention. Torrence said policymakers don’t seem to understand how widespread the problems at such facilities really are.
“It’s not just a couple of us saying we had a bad experience in one of these facilities,” Torrence said. “It’s pretty standard for the kids that go out of there to say they come out of the facilities with more trauma than when they went in.”
People often think of residential youth facilities as something akin to hospitals, said Torrence, while the reality can be much more carceral in nature. That’s why he is also calling on the state to ban residential facilities from using any form of restraint that might make it harder for a child to breathe, and to better enforce existing bans on certain restraint methods.