Rep. Brewer Urges Gov. DeWine to Veto Senate Bill 278, Which Lets 18-Year-Olds Carry Concealed Handguns Without a Pathway to Training

COLUMBUS — State Rep. Darnell T. Brewer (D-Cleveland) today called on Governor Mike DeWine to veto Senate Bill 278, the so-called Freedom to Carry Act, which the Ohio House passed 61–33 and the Senate concurred in 23–8 on Nov. 18. Rep. Brewer voted no.
"I respect the Second Amendment and responsible gun owners," said Rep. Brewer. "But this bill expands who can carry and where, and it offers no pathway to training. Meanwhile, legislation that encourages firearm safety continues to wait its turn."
What Senate Bill 278 Was, and What It Became
Senate Bill 278 began as a measure to amend Section 9.68 of the Ohio Revised Code, allowing individuals to seek punitive or exemplary damages from municipalities that enact or enforce firearm measures that conflict with state law. Ohio already has preemption laws and legal remedies for violations.
In the final hours before the House vote, a substantial substitute amendment folded in additional legislation and turned the bill into the Freedom to Carry Act. The expanded bill had not received committee hearings before it reached the House floor.
As passed, Senate Bill 278:
- Lowers the age for permitless concealed carry of a handgun from 21 to 18, with no license or training required.
- Expands what can be carried: renames the concealed handgun license as a concealed weapons license and lets licensees carry concealed deadly weapons other than exclusive deadly weapons.
- Loosens vehicle rules: allows loaded firearms in motor vehicles and vessels, removing a current restriction.
- Targets cities: lets individuals seek punitive or exemplary damages from municipalities that enact or enforce local gun measures that conflict with state law.
- Places new requirements on sheriffs and restrictions on municipalities.
A Threat to Home Rule and Gun Safety Programs
Senate Bill 278 expands individuals’ ability to sue Ohio cities over firearm measures. Ohio already preempts local gun laws and provides remedies when a city violates preemption. By adding punitive or exemplary damages, Rep. Brewer says, the bill creates a new financial threat that infringes on home rule, the authority Ohio's Constitution gives cities to govern local affairs.
Rep. Brewer also warned that gun safety programs run by cities and community groups could be put in jeopardy. Those voluntary programs include gun-lock distribution, safety education, help buying gun safes, violence intervention, youth violence and suicide prevention, and partnerships with schools, hospitals, and law enforcement. With municipalities now exposed to punitive damages claims, some cities may hesitate to offer them, even though the programs are voluntary and do not regulate firearms.
"Ohio cities should not have to choose between handing out gun locks and risking a lawsuit," said Rep. Brewer. "When a city is sued, taxpayers pay. This is an overreach on home rule, and it comes at the expense of programs that keep families safe. I proposed amendments to protect voluntary safety programs, to require notice and an opportunity to cure, and to safeguard municipal taxpayers. Those concerns remain."
"Training Is the Missing Piece"
Supporters note that 18-year-olds can vote and serve in the armed services. Rep. Brewer says that argument makes his point.
"Those who serve in the armed services are given training before they carry a weapon. Voting comes with voter education. Senate Bill 278 provides no pathway to training," said Rep. Brewer. "We require education and testing before someone gets a driver's license because we know improper operation can cause serious injury or death. We should not expand who can carry a deadly weapon and ask for less."
Priorities: Vending Machines, Yes. Gun Safes, No.
Just last week, the House passed House Bill 762, a sales tax exemption for food from vending machines and micro-markets, by a vote of 91 to 2. Rep. Brewer notes that House Bill 120, which he jointly sponsored with Rep. Jennifer Gross (R-West Chester) and which would exempt firearm safety devices from sales and use tax, has not received the same consideration.
"Why can we find time to exempt vending-machine purchases from sales tax, but not gun locks and gun safes that could save a child's life?" said Rep. Brewer. "A vending machine purchase may save someone a few cents. A properly secured firearm may spare someone a lifetime of grief."
Bills That Could Address Gun Violence
Rep. Brewer has introduced 14 bills this General Assembly that could possibly help address gun violence, including:
- House Bill 120, with Rep. Jennifer Gross, exempting firearm safety devices from sales and use tax.
- House Bill 235, with Rep. Meredith Lawson-Rowe, providing nonrefundable income tax credits for qualifying handgun training and firearm storage devices.
- House Bill 358, providing information on firearm safety and secure storage.
- Amya's Law (HB 901), designed to prevent children from accessing firearms without authorization.
- House Bills 909, 871, 351 and 900, addressing safe storage, awareness, a task force on gun violence, and an Office of Violence Prevention.
"These are incentive-based, not mandate-based, and none of them would take a firearm from a law-abiding citizen," said Rep. Brewer. "Yet again, we fail to address the many bills introduced to possibly address gun violence. Last week, a third grader brought a loaded gun into Oliver H. Perry Elementary School. We should not have to choose between protecting the Second Amendment and protecting Ohio's children."
Call to Action
Rep. Brewer is asking Ohioans to contact Governor DeWine's office and urge him to veto Senate Bill 278. Under the Ohio Constitution, the governor has ten days, excluding Sundays, after the bill is presented to him. Rep. Brewer is also asking colleagues to hold a hearing on the safety and training bills that have been waiting.
"If we can legislate to protect the right to own a firearm, we should also be willing to legislate to promote the responsibility that comes with owning one," said Rep. Brewer. "Governor DeWine, please veto Senate Bill 278."